Spoilers All. Print. I think Jamie makes a mistake in “teaching” Geneva how to get pregnant. Syncretism in the Beliefs of the Scottish Highlanders, Outlander – Rereading Voyager: Jamie’s Arrival at Helwater, Outlander: Symbolism of the Blue Color, How It Relates to Claire, and Jamie’s Ghost, Outlander: Joe Abernathy and Ishmael Foreshadow Geillis’s Death, Outlander: The Use of Lavender Oil in “To Ransom a Man’s Soul”. There are two possible reasons for this mistake. Studied anthropology and literature at the University of Toronto. Their encounter was much sweeter than I expected, probably because Gordon was killed in the Battle of Prestonpans during the Jacobite Rising of 1745; the Dunsanys took the loss very hard, and perhaps as a consequence cherished and spoiled their daughters even more than before. I just read online that Jamie rapes Geneva in the book? In Diana Gabaldon's third installment of the book series, Voyager, a virgin Lady Geneva rebuffs Jamie's advances by telling him, "No," but he continues to push and shove anyway. Courage, to him, was no small virtue (ch.14). Outlander fans were very surprised after Jamie Fraser (played by Sam Heughan) had sex with Geneva Dunsany (Hannah James) in season three. In the moment, she changes her mind, yet he ignores her revoked consent. This post is an idea that came to me while…, After finishing reading Drums of Autumn recently, many thoughts about…, This post is the second one concerning the character analysis…, The first season of Outlander has come to an end…, Readers have different opinions regarding Malva’s love for Claire. Even though she is not willing to be married to the Earl of Ellesmere, Geneva knows there is no way out of it. While serving as groomsman at the aristocratic estate of Helwater, Jamie is reluctantly pulled into the intrigue of a noble British family. I don't have the exact page number, but when Jaime agrees to fulfill his end of the bargain (or should I say blackmail), he specifically tells her that she should not shedule the encounter two weeks after her menses so that she does not risk pregnancy. Keep up with your favorite shows... delivered to your inbox! A história de Outlander se tornou bastante popular e, por isso, acabou gerando muitas perguntas como, por exemplo: por que Jamie Fraser mentiu para Claire sobre seu filho com Geneva Dunsany? He probably thought that Geneva’s feelings for him were just an infatuation as opposed to love. Both feature Jaime (Sam Heughan) and one features Geneva (Hannah James), a character we will learn more about soon. But what led Jamie to stray from his beloved wife Claire Fraser (Caitriona Balfe)? This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. ASoIaF: Highlights of Episode 510 – “Mother’s Mercy” and Some Speculations for the Sixth Season, Outlander: Possible Origin of Black Jack’s Depravity, My Outlander Essay is About Ghosts, Symbolism and Astral Body Projections, Jamie Fraser as a Half-Ghost (Asgina Ageli). Outlander Book 3. Furthermore, female choice is typical is modern Western society. Outlander S03E04 - Jamie and Geneva. Required fields are marked *. It's not clear that she realized the extent of the threat she was making - I got the impression that she was too immature to have thought through all the consequences of her threatened action - but she was pretty obnoxious in getting what she wanted. Of course, Jamie considers her love for him as another prohibition to the deal between them. Of course, he was trying to prevent an undesirable pregnancy. 22 Apr by Piolina. Why did Jamie Fraser sleep with Laoghaire MacKenzie? This thread is archived. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. Very well made! I would definitely encourage you to take a look at it. It’s her voice talking directly to you, the reader. As a result, Geneva seems to be not a woman of her time, probably one of the main reasons why I sympathize with her (a little bit, though). She is selfish and concerned about herself only. Copyright © 2020 NTVB Media, Inc., All Rights Reserved, 'Outlander': Sam Heughan Teases Jamie and Claire's 'Passionate, Emotional' Reunion, Worth Watching: George Clooney's 'Midnight Sky,' 'Buddy's Recovery,' 'Meet Me in St. Louis,' 'Christmas Light' Finale, Deeks' Journey to Become an Agent Officially Begins on 'NCIS: LA' (PHOTOS), 'Outlander's Sam Heughan on 2020, From 'Elf' to Learning He's a Good Driver (VIDEO), 'GH's Laura Wright on What Could Be the Worst Christmas Ever, The 9 Best Holiday Commercials Spreading Cheer in a Difficult Year, 'The Bachelorette' Finale: Tayshia Chooses Her Man (RECAP). Readers do not like the fact that she blackmails Jamie to have sex with her without taking into consideration the lives of others. Producer Matthew B. Roberts tells EW about "Of Lost Things," casting the role of Jamie's son Willie, and why the sex isn't the same between Jamie and Geneva as it is Jamie and Claire. Most of what readers know about Geneva comes from Jamie’s point of view. He never mentions anything negative about her. I dealt with this topic in the following post using as an example the blood types. Yeah, I see your point. Love cats and birds. 14). 73. How Did She Know About Jamie’s Scars? In the book, it all works because Diane [Gabaldon] is telling you the story, and she’s telling it to you in a very specific way. share. Saved by Virtual Crush. One of the characters that readers tend to dislike is Geneva Dunsany. Marriages between the English and the Scottish were uncommon. (ch. In the moment, she changes her mind, yet he ignores her revoked consent. 3 Voyager. Jamie (Sam Heughan) was coerced into sex by Geneva … Feb 1, 2018 - Season 3 is here! That she blackmails him but then backs out and he rapes her?? Outlander has never shied away from a shocking sex scene, but fans might have been a wee bit taken aback by what they saw last night. Furthermore, Jamie does see some positive characteristics in Geneva. She ended up pregnant and gave birth to William Ransom. Born the second child and eldest daughter of Lord and Lady Dunsany, Geneva was raised alongside her older brother, Gordon, and younger sister, Isobel. She has in her possession a letter from him to his sister which provides information about the Frenchman’s gold. In 1968 Scotland, Claire, Brianna and Roger struggle to trace Jamie's whereabouts in history, leaving Claire to wonder if they will ever find him again. Jamie was left in between a rock and a hard place after he was blackmailed by Geneva into sleeping with her. His sister, Ian, their six children, all the tenants and families at Lallybroch – perhaps even the lives of the agents who carried messages and money between Scotland and France, maintaining the precarious existence of the Jacobite exiles there (ch. William has always believed that the eight Earl of Ellesmere, Ludovic Ransom is his father. This, what you feel from me – ye can have that with any man, it’s not particular (ch. 'Outlander' recap: Season 3, episode 4, "Of Lost Things," gives Jamie (Sam Heughan) a chance to experience fatherhood with an unexpected son, Willie. Producer Matthew B. Roberts tells EW about "Of Lost Things," casting the role of Jamie's son Willie, and why the sex isn't the same between Jamie and Geneva as it is Jamie and Claire. Obviously controversial, it depicts Jamie, the hero, morally compromised. With Caitriona Balfe, Sam Heughan, Richard Rankin, Sophie Skelton. Outlander Book 3 Outlander Funny Outlander Season 3 Outlander Quotes Outlander Casting Sam Heughan Outlander Jaime Fraser I Movie Wayfarer. A couple of new official photos from future episodes of season three of Outlander have hit the interwebs. However, he is a prisoner and a former traitor, which is what others see at Helwater. So schafft es der Outlander-Charakter auch, Jamie Fraser gegen seinen Willen zu einer gemeinsamen Nacht zu erpressen. Outlander S03E04 - Jamie and Geneva. Therefore, there is a tradeoff. Executive producers Ronald D. Moore and Meril Davis spoke to Decider about the thought process behind editing or deleting scenes for Outlander. Most of what readers know about Geneva comes from Jamie’s point of … Directed by Brendan Maher. Of interest is the fact that she chooses to have a son from Jamie eventually (she got pregnant on purpose). New York: Bantam Dell. Jamie muses how many lives are endangered just because of her whimsy nature: He thought he might be sick on the spot, from sheer terror. Outlander returns November 4 to STARZ. The passage above is what Jamie thinks when Geneva tells him that she would not mind the pain during intercourse. The grand romance between Jamie … As we journeyed our way through Outlander Season 3 and the ultimate reunion of Jamie and Claire, we made a few pit stops along the way that involved Jamie kissing other women (gasp). She didn’t want to lose her virginity to a man she didn’t even like, let alone love. Jamie’s standout moments from Outlander Season 3, Episode 4. However some fans have questioned the scene and its ambiguous sex scene and whether the Highlander was forced into something against his will. Hannah James as Geneva in “Outlander.” (Photo: Starz) Warning: This post contains spoilers for the “Of Lost Things” episode of Outlander.. Het nog altijd enorm succesvolle Doctor Who vormde een van de inspiratiebronnen voor Outlander.Op een avond keek schrijver Diana Gabaldon naar een oude aflevering van de serie, waarin het personage Jamie McCrimmon … Sort by. However some fans have questioned the scene and its ambiguous sex scene and whether the Highlander was forced into something against his will. Prior to the scene, Geneva wanted to have sex with Jamie. Outlander CZX: DW11 Jamie & Geneva" Dual Wardrobe Costume Card #056/200Features:OUTLANDER CZX(CRYPTOZOIC ENTERTAINMENT)DW11 Double Wardrobe Card "Jamie & Geneva… Outlander has never shied away from a shocking sex scene, but fans might have been a wee bit taken aback by what they saw last night. Geneva becoming the mother of Jamie's son made navigating her coercion that much more of a grey area. He acquiesces and sneaks into her chambers late at night to perform the deed. Sunday night's episode of Outlander, "Of Lost Things," featured an intense and intimate sex scene between Jamie Fraser (Sam Heughan) and Lady Geneva Dunsany (Hannah James). Sunday night's episode of Outlander, "Of Lost Things," featured an intense and intimate sex scene between Jamie Fraser (Sam Heughan) and Lady Geneva Dunsany (Hannah James). She threatened to reveal he was a Jacobite to her mother, which could have landed him in big trouble. Turning to Jamie for this wasn’t all that surprising. “Sometime in the week after ye’ve finished your courses,” he said bluntly. The scene is about Jamie taking comfort in someone that he doesn’t love. Jamie is terrified, and this terror is probably the main reason for him not being able to devise a way to get out of this blackmailing. In the book, there’s a question of whether or not Jamie rapes Geneva, because he does say, ‘When I start I won’t be able to stop.’ And she does at one point say, ‘No, no.’ And he continues. 14). 5. 73. Outlander Casting Diana Gabaldon Diana Gabaldon Last night, Outlander tackled one of the most controversial moments from the books on which it's based: Jamie's sex scene with Geneva. The second and third points show a brave young woman. Jamie slept with Geneva while working as an indentured servant at the Helwater Estate in England. One of the characters that readers tend to dislike is Geneva Dunsany. It was a … This passage is taken from the scene in which Geneva is blackmailing him to have sex with her. Het grote liefdesverhaal tussen Claire en Jamie mag dan wel de rode draad zijn van Outlander, toch maakt het koppel het één en ander mee gedurende hun 20-jarige scheiding van elkaar. Geneva was undoubtedly reckless and definitely planned to get pregnant with Jaime's child. . Outlander Book 3. It is a desirable trait for them, and they want those physical traits to be transferred to their offsprings. But in the Starz drama, both Jamie and Lady Geneva consent to the encounter. 21 comments. On the day of William Ransom's birth, he lost not only his mother, Geneva Dunsany, but also his father, the Earl of Ellesmere, whose official cause of death was 'misadventure'. Furthermore, he even provides information to Geneva of when to get pregnant. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. If Geneva is seen with the twentieth-century mindset, she is a teenager with “silly” hormones aspiring for a good-looking man whom she frequently meets. And being a victim of rape himself, you'd think he'd be more sensitive. Saved by Virtual Crush. I guess the answer lies in Geneva’s behavior after the intercourse. Voor veel fans van Outlander was de scène tussen Jamie en Geneva in de afgelopen aflevering, Of Lost Things waarschijnlijk al niet erg gemakkelijk om te zien. Gabaldon, Diana. 4. Bilingual. Jamie slept with Geneva … Of course, Jamie’s background is refined as her. She wanted someone who would be kind to her, something that almost all women would have wanted (and still want). . There have definitely been scenes we’ve cut and elements of sexual threat and violence that we didn’t play. The grand romance between Jamie … Wow! 1994. . Oké, het was fijn om te zien dat Jamie zijn leven weer een beetje weet op te pakken en weer kan genieten van intimiteit, maar natuurlijk hadden we veel liever gezien dat Jamie weer het bed zou delen met Claire. At the end of the latest Outlander episode, titled "Creme de Menthe," Jamie realizes it's time to take young Ian back to his parents, Jenny and Ian, Outlander S03E04 - Jamie and Geneva. Jamie slept with Geneva while working as an indentured servant at the Helwater Estate in England. So it’s a creative choice that you make. 14). Geneva giving Jamie grief. In fact, he is even better than her (he is not spoiled). Like Jamie, I could feel some pity for Geneva, but that doesn't excuse her blackmail and threats to his family. Jamie clearly likes the boy. Outlander- Rereading Voyager: Let’s Talk About Geneva. Love pink and purple. In fact, Jamie uses this attribute of her being brave and courageous to describe her to his son, William, in book 8. Warning: I may be talking about events from this episode, other episodes, and/or the book series... so if you'd rather not know, now's your chance to… Geneva, played by the excellent Hannah James, understandably didn’t want to marry this man. We decided not to include that part, merely because that’s not what the scene is about. Jamie was blackmailed by Geneva Dunsany—the daughter of Lord and Lady Dunsany—into getting intimate. Is that rape? A good example of this female choice is the male peacock. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. She objects to the marriage contract that her father has arranged for her. Geneva becoming the mother of Jamie's son made navigating her coercion that much more of a grey area. She chooses him to accompany her all the time she goes for a ride. He tells her she can watch him strip, something many of us have imagined Jamie Fraser offering to do. With Caitriona Balfe, Sam Heughan, Richard Rankin, Sophie Skelton. Because Jamie has this effect on literally everyone he encounters anywhere ever, one of the daughters, Geneva, becomes infatuated with the large, brooding Scottish groom. Big fan of kettle bell and kickboxing workouts. Outlander viewers are still buzzing about one particular moment from last Sunday's episode: when Jamie (Sam Heughan) and Geneva (Hannah James) have sex. So schafft es der Outlander-Charakter auch, Jamie Fraser gegen seinen Willen zu einer gemeinsamen Nacht zu erpressen. “You’re less likely to get wi’ child then.”. Outlander S03E04 - Jamie and Geneva. Your email address will not be published. It brings to the mind the concept of “female choice,” a form of sexual selection, typical of many animal species. Of course, he does not like much about her. Pinterest addict. After having sex with Jamie, she proclaims she loves him. I tend to suspect that most people used to marry somebody of the same “nationality” in the past. Outlander season three arrived at a pivotal moment from the book in Sunday's episode when Jamie is blackmailed by Geneva Dunsany into sleeping with her, which leads to the birth of Jamie… Hannah James as Geneva in “Outlander.” (Photo: Starz) Warning: This post contains spoilers for the “Of Lost Things” episode of Outlander.. Geneva is not allowed to love him. This…, <<<<<<>>>>>> In comparison to other Game of Thrones’ season…, In Drums of Autumn there are references to Brianna having…, Recently, a moderator from Outlander Series, a Facebook Outlander Fan…, For almost a year I have been mentioning about some…, This is the third of a series of Outlander posts…. She is attracted to Jamie, a feeling which is evident to many around (other grooms notice that). Outlander is geïnspireerd door Doctor Who. I can't say that … Here is a description of Geneva from Jamie’s perspective: Pretty, spoilt, and autocratic, the Lady Geneva was accustomed to get what she wanted when she wanted it, and damn the convenience of anyone standing in her way. Outlander news, rumors, updates, casting, character updates and more. 4 comments. S P O I L E R Diana Gabaldon has posted a very long and detailed analysis on Facebook on the topic of whether Jamie's encounter with Geneva in VOYAGER qualifies as rape. Read at your own risk! “Oh.” She blushed rosily at that, but looked at him with a new interest (Voyager, ch. The fourth episode featured Highland warrior Jamie Fraser, played by Sam Heughan, welcoming a baby boy in the 18th century with Geneva - who he was blackmailed into having sex with. Furthermore, she does not follow the rules. OUTLANDER fans saw Jamie Fraser blackmailed into sleeping with Lady Geneva Dunsany. As a result of their dual passing, William was raised by his mother's sister, Isobel, and her husband, Lord Jo… Saved by Mary Ann "Mac Attack" 1. 38. Jamie arrives in Geneva’s bedroom to discover her all heated up and ready to go. Saved by Virtual Crush. When it comes to sex, one might say that Geneva is naive, and it is confusing love and sex. It’s … . Geneva was a young lady whose family arranged her marriage to the much older earl, and she died from childbirth complications soon after William was born. As detailed in my previous post, everybody at Helwater is scared of Jamie – who is seen as an uncouth Highlander, except her. Jamie arrives in Geneva’s bedroom to discover her all heated up and ready to go. 50% Upvoted. The Ballad of Roger Mac - Season 5, Episode 7. Outlander had to make her redeemable in some fashion, without making her behavior seem acceptable. Fans of Outlander were left shocked after Jamie Fraser (played by Sam Heughan) slept with Geneva Dunsany (Hannah James) in season three of the Starz drama. One wonders whether Geneva was able to see Jamie’s refinement. Outlander: Did Malva love Claire? While serving as groomsman at the aristocratic estate of Helwater, Jamie is reluctantly pulled into the intrigue of a noble British family. Outlander- Rereading Voyager: Let’s Talk About Geneva. He reveals to her that he loves Claire without even mentioning her name: “Well, love’s for only one person. An Outlander AU based loosely on the TV Show and real life in the historic Jamestown. Jamie was 'never raped' by Geneva on Outlander, actress Hannah James says By Lynette Rice October 04, 2017 at 01:42 PM EDT Outlander: Reprodução. Mother of two little boys. 14).”. Die junge Geneva Dunsany bekommt immer das, was sie will. save hide report. While Claire searched for any trace of Jamie during Outlander Season 3, Episode 4, Jamie faced heartbreak and turmoil. Plus, the Scottish actor gives us a sneak peek at his latest venture: the Sam Heughan Signature Collection with U.K. brand Barbour. On her family's large estate, Geneva enjoyed handling and riding horses, po… Contributor to ADORING OUTLANDER. This assessment of Geneva is accurate, and it foreshadows what will subsequently happen between Jamie and her. Entertainment Weekly also released a new photo from their Outlander photo shoot with Caitriona Balfe and Sam Heughan. She essentially blackmailed him into sleeping with her by threatening to expose his true Jacobite rebel identity to her British family. He tells her she can watch him strip, something many of us have imagined Jamie Fraser offering to do. Never thought of Geneva in this way. She is interested in somebody who is not at the same social level. Move over Casablanca. I mean, seriously, just... BLAH. He is scared of what might happen if his letter falls into the wrong hands. She pushes Jamie to ride with her in the foothills above Helwater, even though she is forbidden to go there. Jamie Fraser y Geneva Dunsany en la tercera temporada de Outlander Recordemos que después de la batalla de Culloden , Jamie y Claire se separan por 20 años aproximadamente, ya que ella regresa a su época por protección. Of course, one of the biggest disadvantages is that being colorful makes the male peacock visual to predators. My intention is to write an "Insta-Reaction" post for each episode soon after viewing, to share some initial thoughts, questions, reactions -- you name it. Published author. Outlander viewers are still buzzing about one particular moment from last Sunday's episode: when Jamie (Sam Heughan) and Geneva (Hannah James) have sex. Your email address will not be published. save. Outlander fans were very surprised after Jamie Fraser (played by Sam Heughan) had sex with Geneva Dunsany (Hannah James) in season three. Finally, I would like to mention that scene in which Geneva tells Jamie to stop and he refuses. Of course, many women in the past probably did not like their match in the past, but they still accepted their father’s choice. Outlander S03E04 - Jamie and Geneva. She might be spoilt, selfish, and reckless, but there was some character to her, at least. Jamie and Geneva. Outlander Book 3 Outlander Funny Outlander Season 3 Outlander Quotes Outlander Casting Sam Heughan Outlander Diana Gabaldon Jaime Fraser American Series. Obsessed with fashion trends, Outlander, and A Song of Ice and Fire. Did she have the faintest idea how many lives lay in the manicured white hand? Outlander Book 3 Outlander Funny Outlander Season 3 Outlander Quotes Outlander Casting Sam Heughan Outlander Jaime Fraser I Movie Wayfarer. Learn how your comment data is processed. Whatever’s coming in the new world, Claire and Jamie will face it together. She does not exhibit any trauma and is looking forward to continuing having subsequent intercourses with Jamie. Furthermore, she is willing to have sexual intercourse with somebody who is not English and considered a barbarian. She has good looks and is skilled at riding horses. If you haven't read VOYAGER (Book 3 of the OUTLANDER series), there are Major Spoilers below. Was she in love with him? She would like to lose her virginity with somebody of her choice. Tags: 135, Geneva Dunsany, Hannah James, Helwater, Jamie Fraser, Lord Dunsany, Lord Ellesmere, Of Lost Things, sam heughan, seizoen 3, William The girl we all love to hate: Geneva Dunsany. But there were times when I thought it was really important to the story. But what had people talking wasn't Fraser's derrière (although we appreciate it), but rather it was what the showrunners decided to omit. I think he feared (rightly as it turned out) that the child would turn out resemble him too much and then there would be hell to pay. But he feels empathy for this character even though he’s coerced into Geneva’s bed, he still feels like he wants, as a gentleman, for it to be a satisfying or non-threatening experience for her.". Voyager. It makes me want to skip to when Claire and Jamie are back together. hide. Always aiming in writing something new, speculative and different. . Thanks!!! report. WARNING: This article contains spoiler from Outlander season 3. Why did Jamie Fraser really sleep with Geneva Dunsany in Outlander? share. Directed by Brendan Maher. Jamie (Sam Heughan) was coerced into sex by Geneva … Season three of Outlander is adapted from Voyager, the corresponding novel in Diana Gabaldon’s novel series.. OUTLANDER fans saw Jamie Fraser blackmailed into sleeping with Lady Geneva Dunsany. It’s time to look back at his strongest moments from the episode. 2002. It kind of just pisses me off. An Outlander AU based loosely on the TV Show and real life in the historic Jamestown. Thanks for reading and hope you find this post enjoyable! Of course, there are exceptions, especially when monarchs married foreigners to create alliances. Outlander had to make her redeemable in some fashion, without making her … If Outlander has taught us anything, it’s that sometimes a kiss isn’t just a kiss.Here’s our look at the ways kissing in Outlander reflects Jamie’s growth as a man. Covering all seasons of Outlander as well as the books by Diana Gabaldon. The historical period drama saw Jamie having sex with the character while he served as an indentured servant at the Helwater Estate in England.